Mariah wins.......unfortunately

i consider myself the biggest whitney fan as i'm sure everyone considers themselves. but in WYB as far as a better voice mariah wins. i'm not to say that our sweetheart (oops, isn't that mariah's song) doesn't shine. but i am saying that the song does sound like a mariah song therefore if it sounds like a mariah carey sound who do you think is going to sound better in it?